I’ve always liked computers, but I’ve never been a huge fan of overwrought TV media setups. You end up having 10 components with 15 remotes and 20,000 buttons, most of which have redundant or never-used functionality. The setup takes up a great deal of space and sucks up a bunch of energy through 10,000 different cables and wires.
Several changes have happened in the last few years, simple but significant, to change the TV media ball game.
1. HDMI
HDMI = HDTV as computer screen
HDMI is the digital video/audio connection for HDTV. Previous connectors required 5 separate connectors, all usually bundled into the same cable (ugh!). HDMI bundles everything into the same connection. So okay… we’ve simplified one out of 20 million cables. Not bad.
The really cool thing about HDMI is that it uses the same digital video signal as computer screens (DVI). You can spend $5 on an HDMI/DVI adaptor and another $5 on a cheap HDMI cable, displaying computer content on the TV for $10.
2. Internet Video
With sites like Hulu, YouTube, and Netflix, file transfer protocols like BitTorrent, and services like iTunes, people have easy and cheap access to movies and shows to play on their computers.
Combining #2 and #1 is a no brainer — all you need is a $10 cable to watch Hulu on your HDTV. Hollywood doesn’t want you to know this though, because the entrenched industry doesn’t want you to stop paying separately for HD cable TV. They want to control exactly how you pay for the content, regardless of what is technologically possible. They want it so bad that they’ve infected hardware manufacturers with crippling technologies like HDCP.
3. Video game systems similar to computers.
Video game systems have always been computers, but traditionally (NES, SNES, N64, etc.) they’ve been hard to recognize because they’re so specialized. But since 2000, video game systems have been converging with computers.
A mac mini today is $600. At release, Playstation 3 was $600. Both come with hard drive, RAM, a drive for movie playing discs, digital video output, and a wireless internet connection. Both are capable of running traditional PC operating systems (Linux being the obvious choice).
This convergence has changed people’s expectations about what the big screen in the living room should be used for. If a customer pays $600 for a Playstation 3, they feel like they should get their money’s worth. So they’ll try out the audio player. They’ll try out the blu-ray player, the picture viewer, the web browser. Some of these features will stick, and people will use them over and over again. Others will fail, either because the interface is bad or because a competing activity or option wins out.
Today, the living room media landscape is much different than twenty years ago. Here are a few more examples:
1. Sling Box. A device that allows you to view the Cable TV you have at home from the Internet. If you’re traveling with your laptop, you can watch HBO from the airport.
2. Apple Airtunes. A device that allows you to listen to music on your computer from somewhere else in the house. Wireless means that you don’t have to have your speakers and your computer in the same location. Speakers on the patio — computer in the bedroom.
3. Sony LocationFree. Watch the DVR in your living room on the little TV in your bathroom.
4. Popcorn Hour. A box that allows you to download BitTorrent and Internet content, save it on a hard drive, and watch it on your TV.
5. OnLive. An online service that allows you to play really fancy video games without owning fancy video game hardware. All you need is a modestly powerful computer and a good internet connection.
In the past few years, the number of options for the living room has exploded. Some of the stuff is cool — but most of it fails for one reason or another. The industry is trying to “get it right,” both in terms of providing appealing new abilities to consumers as well as providing themselves with new profit opportunities.
If you’re in the market for a big TV and a nice couch potato setup, you have two options. You can either go back to school and get a degree in living room media setups, or you can throw your money at the shiniest box at Best Buy with no real idea of what’s going on. Yes, I think it’s really that bad.
I’ve noticed most other people my age think it’s that bad too. That’s why most aren’t buying TV media hardware. Instead, they’re watching Hulu or Netflix on their computer. Occasionally, they’ll spiff it up with one thing or another — maybe an external set of speakers (2 small ones and a subwoofer). Maybe they have an XBox 360 for video games, and they’ll watch streaming Netflix on the TV they use for video games. But there isn’t a single reliable option that most people are going for. The most popular living room appliance among young people I know is the laptop. The most popular monthly service is Netflix.
Nevertheless, I’ve been on a quest to fill my living room full of crap. Technology begets more technology. If you buy a nice digital camera, you have to take a bunch of photos to justify the money spent. If you have a bunch of photos, you have to buy a hard drive to store them. If you buy an iPod, you need music to fill it. The music needs a hard drive. If you have a bunch of cool music to play, what’s the point if your speakers suck? Well, if you’re going to get speakers, they might as well be surround sound. Now that you have surround sound and a bunch of cool photos, why not buy a nice TV? You already have that video game system with blu-ray, you already watch Netflix — it would have a lot of value.
And before you know it, you have all this stuff. In my case, it’s about like this:
1. Samsung 46 inch LCD HDTV
2. Sony PS3
3. Xbox 360
4. Nintendo Wii
5. Mac Mini
6. 500GB hard drive
7. Sony Receiver
8. Boston 5.1 surround sound
And that’s not even mentioning the other stuff…
So once you have all this stuff, it becomes a question — what don’t you need? Many devices have redundant functionality. Xbox 360 and PS3 games are the same, but Xbox 360 has streaming Netflix (PS3 doesn’t), and PS3 has a blu-ray player (Xbox 360 doesn’t). Could I just upgrade the internal hard drive of the Mac mini, and get rid of the external one? The Wii isn’t high definition . . . but it does have Mario (and Mario is really friggin’ fun). Do I really need a receiver, or should I sell the receiver and surround sound to pay for a surround system with a built-in amplifier?
At the time of purchase, I rationalized the purchases in different ways. I spent all night at Best Buy trying to get a PS3 at launch — I sold it for $1600, so really I had $1000 profit from that one. I got the 5.1 surround sound system for $100 bucks (a $600 system) when Circuit City went out of business. The mac mini I bought because I wanted to run a webserver from home, to learn how to setup apache/php/mysql from scratch, so I would have full control over a website. I also wanted to house all of my photos, music, and video at one location (not my laptop), about 200GB of data. The Wii I bought because the other two systems weren’t as social — I wanted something I could play with friends. The XBox 360 I waited and waited to get, because I heard about them overheating. I wanted to play the new Halo.
At the time, everything made sense. But now that I have them, I notice I don’t play many video games anymore. The mac mini can do streaming Netflix, so the PS3 is the only video game system that is used often (for Netflix blu-rays). The mac mini is actually getting more use as a media center than as a webserver right now because I’m not paying for internet access (and therefore can’t justify running a website off a mooched internet connection). Seeing the stuff day after day has led me to think about how I might simplify it if I could do it again.
The answer?
Wall mounted HDTV + mac mini + 2.1 sound system with built-in amp (bose is quite good). The $9.99 netflix subscription, and a decent (3 Mbp +) internet connection.
Since I haven’t installed the 5.1 speakers on the wall, the “surround” aspect is overrated. The best part of it is the base response.
The mac mini can handle streaming netflix, which is how I watch most of my movies. It can’t do blu-ray, but eventually I’d be able to buy a USB blu-ray player (and Apple’s software would support blu-ray playback). DVDs look good, and they can be ripped and saved (unlike blu-ray). The video game systems have been fun, but at the moment I’m more focused on activities like reading and writing. The computer has the added benefit of being able to check up on e-mail/facebook/twitter just by switching from one desktop to another — literally 2 button presses on a small bluetooth keyboard.
I’ve wanted to believe that specialized interfaces like remotes and video game controllers are a lot better than a wireless keyboard and mouse for TV. But I haven’t found that to be the case. You end up having a lot of remotes (in my case, at least 5: wii, ps3, xbox, receiver, TV), when you could just have a keyboard and mouse to handle everything.
Surfing the internet on the TV is begging for eyestrain.
$600 for a mac mini can seem steep compared to
$200 for Wii,
$250 for XBox 360, or
$300 for a PS3,
but mac mini offers an unparalleled feature set. By having a standard web browser, the mac mini gives you everything on the Internet — so much stuff that I wouldn’t be able to list everything in this note. More audio and video content than you can shake a stick at. The Mac mini, unlike the Wii, is capable of playing HD video, so all you have to do is find the HD content (streaming Netflix, iTunes, YouTube, BitTorrent, etc.) And there are enough games capable of running well on the mac mini that, although the graphics won’t necessarily be as good as XBox 360 or a high end PC, all but the pickiest and most hardcore gamers can be satisfied.
The mac mini is about to be refreshed. The 2009 mac mini (what I have) plays HD content without any trouble, mainly due to the updated NVIDIA GeForce 9400M graphics card. The new mini will no doubt be more capable, smaller, and/or cheaper, so there’s no doubt in my mind it will be an excellent machine to connect to an HDTV.
The setup I’ve described also has very few cables.
A word of caution. The mac mini runs best when at least two memory slots are filled. This means you can get a great performance boost for $70 (2 2GB ram sticks). Doing this upgrade requires you to open up the machine though, which is a bit tricky (but not impossible). In the process of upgrading my own machine, I stripped one of the tiny screws while putting it back together (doh!) and broke a little plastic piece connected to a wifi antenna. This has no impact on the performance of the machine, but it does void my warranty (which will be up soon anyway) and make it more difficult for me to upgrade the internal hard drive. Upgrading the hard drive is something I’d want to do ideally, since then I wouldn’t have to have an external drive, which is actually bigger than the mini itself and adds unnecessary cords and power consumption.
Downsides. The mac mini’s DVD drive is louder than others, but not intolerable. The cost isn’t ideal but is justified by the benefits. The mac mini doesn’t play blu-rays, so you won’t be able to take full advantage of the “HDTV experience,” but the online HD content is good enough, and I expect it will only get better with time. Reading on the tav kinda sucks, not going to lie, but if you pump up the magnification in the web browser, it’s not absolutely terrible. You won’t be reading novels off it though (get a refurbished Kindle for that).
I’ve always liked computers, but I’ve never been a huge fan of overwrought TV media setups. You end up having 10 components with 15 remotes and 20,000 buttons, most of which have redundant or never-used functionality. The setup takes up a great deal of space and sucks up a bunch of energy through 10,000 different cables and wires.
Several changes have happened in the last few years, simple but significant, to change the TV media ball game.
1. HDMI
HDMI = HDTV as computer screen
HDMI is the digital video/audio connection for HDTV. Previous connectors required 5 separate connectors, all usually bundled into the same cable (ugh!). HDMI bundles everything into the same connection. So okay… we’ve simplified one out of 20 million cables. Not bad.
The really cool thing about HDMI is that it uses the same digital video signal as computer screens (DVI). You can spend $5 on an HDMI/DVI adaptor and another $5 on a cheap HDMI cable, displaying computer content on the TV for $10.
2. Internet Video
With sites like Hulu, YouTube, and Netflix, file transfer protocols like BitTorrent, and services like iTunes, people have easy and cheap access to movies and shows to play on their computers.
Combining #2 and #1 is a no brainer — all you need is a $10 cable to watch Hulu on your HDTV. Hollywood doesn’t want you to know this though, because the entrenched industry doesn’t want you to stop paying separately for HD cable TV. They want to control exactly how you pay for the content, regardless of what is technologically possible. They want it so bad that they’ve infected hardware manufacturers with crippling technologies like HDCP.
3. Video game systems similar to computers.
Video game systems have always been computers, but traditionally (NES, SNES, N64, etc.) they’ve been hard to recognize because they’re so specialized. But since 2000, video game systems have been converging with computers.
A mac mini today is $600. At release, Playstation 3 was $600. Both come with hard drive, RAM, a drive for movie playing discs, digital video output, and a wireless internet connection. Both are capable of running traditional PC operating systems (Linux being the obvious choice).
This convergence has changed people’s expectations about what the big screen in the living room should be used for. If a customer pays $600 for a Playstation 3, they feel like they should get their money’s worth. So they’ll try out the audio player. They’ll try out the blu-ray player, the picture viewer, the web browser. Some of these features will stick, and people will use them over and over again. Others will fail, either because the interface is bad or because a competing activity or option wins out.
Today, the living room media landscape is much different than twenty years ago. Here are a few more examples:
1. Sling Box. A device that allows you to view the Cable TV you have at home from the Internet. If you’re traveling with your laptop, you can watch HBO from the airport.
2. Apple Airtunes. A device that allows you to listen to music on your computer from somewhere else in the house. Wireless means that you don’t have to have your speakers and your computer in the same location. Speakers on the patio — computer in the bedroom.
3. Sony LocationFree. Watch the DVR in your living room on the little TV in your bathroom.
4. Popcorn Hour. A box that allows you to download BitTorrent and Internet content, save it on a hard drive, and watch it on your TV.
5. OnLive. An online service that allows you to play really fancy video games without owning fancy video game hardware. All you need is a modestly powerful computer and a good internet connection.
In the past few years, the number of options for the living room has exploded. Some of the stuff is cool — but most of it fails for one reason or another. The industry is trying to “get it right,” both in terms of providing appealing new abilities to consumers as well as providing themselves with new profit opportunities.
If you’re in the market for a big TV and a nice couch potato setup, you have two options. You can either go back to school and get a degree in living room media setups, or you can throw your money at the shiniest box at Best Buy with no real idea of what’s going on. Yes, I think it’s really that bad.
I’ve noticed most other people my age think it’s that bad too. That’s why most aren’t buying TV media hardware. Instead, they’re watching Hulu or Netflix on their computer. Occasionally, they’ll spiff it up with one thing or another — maybe an external set of speakers (2 small ones and a subwoofer). Maybe they have an XBox 360 for video games, and they’ll watch streaming Netflix on the TV they use for video games. But there isn’t a single reliable option that most people are going for. The most popular living room appliance among young people I know is the laptop. The most popular monthly service is Netflix.
Nevertheless, I’ve been on a quest to fill my living room full of crap. Technology begets more technology. If you buy a nice digital camera, you have to take a bunch of photos to justify the money spent. If you have a bunch of photos, you have to buy a hard drive to store them. If you buy an iPod, you need music to fill it. The music needs a hard drive. If you have a bunch of cool music to play, what’s the point if your speakers suck? Well, if you’re going to get speakers, they might as well be surround sound. Now that you have surround sound and a bunch of cool photos, why not buy a nice TV? You already have that video game system with blu-ray, you already watch Netflix — it would have a lot of value.
And before you know it, you have all this stuff. In my case, it’s about like this:
1. Samsung 46 inch LCD HDTV
2. Sony PS3
3. Xbox 360
4. Nintendo Wii
5. Mac Mini
6. 500GB hard drive
7. Sony Receiver
8. Boston 5.1 surround sound
And that’s not even mentioning the other stuff…
So once you have all this stuff, it becomes a question — what don’t you need? Many devices have redundant functionality. Xbox 360 and PS3 games are the same, but Xbox 360 has streaming Netflix (PS3 doesn’t), and PS3 has a blu-ray player (Xbox 360 doesn’t). Could I just upgrade the internal hard drive of the Mac mini, and get rid of the external one? The Wii isn’t high definition . . . but it does have Mario (and Mario is really friggin’ fun). Do I really need a receiver, or should I sell the receiver and surround sound to pay for a surround system with a built-in amplifier?
At the time of purchase, I rationalized the purchases in different ways. I spent all night at Best Buy trying to get a PS3 at launch — I sold it for $1600, so really I had $1000 profit from that one. I got the 5.1 surround sound system for $100 bucks (a $600 system) when Circuit City went out of business. The mac mini I bought because I wanted to run a webserver from home, to learn how to setup apache/php/mysql from scratch, so I would have full control over a website. I also wanted to house all of my photos, music, and video at one location (not my laptop), about 200GB of data. The Wii I bought because the other two systems weren’t as social — I wanted something I could play with friends. The XBox 360 I waited and waited to get, because I heard about them overheating. I wanted to play the new Halo.
At the time, everything made sense. But now that I have them, I notice I don’t play many video games anymore. The mac mini can do streaming Netflix, so the PS3 is the only video game system that is used often (for Netflix blu-rays). The mac mini is actually getting more use as a media center than as a webserver right now because I’m not paying for internet access (and therefore can’t justify running a website off a mooched internet connection). Seeing the stuff day after day has led me to think about how I might simplify it if I could do it again.
The answer?
Wall mounted HDTV + mac mini + 2.1 sound system with built-in amp (bose is quite good). The $9.99 netflix subscription, and a decent (3 Mbp +) internet connection.
Since I haven’t installed the 5.1 speakers on the wall, the “surround” aspect is overrated. The best part of it is the base response.
The mac mini can handle streaming netflix, which is how I watch most of my movies. It can’t do blu-ray, but eventually I’d be able to buy a USB blu-ray player (and Apple’s software would support blu-ray playback). DVDs look good, and they can be ripped and saved (unlike blu-ray). The video game systems have been fun, but at the moment I’m more focused on activities like reading and writing. The computer has the added benefit of being able to check up on e-mail/facebook/twitter just by switching from one desktop to another — literally 2 button presses on a small bluetooth keyboard.
I’ve wanted to believe that specialized interfaces like remotes and video game controllers are a lot better than a wireless keyboard and mouse for TV. But I haven’t found that to be the case. You end up having a lot of remotes (in my case, at least 5: wii, ps3, xbox, receiver, TV), when you could just have a keyboard and mouse to handle everything.
Surfing the internet on the TV is begging for eyestrain.
$600 for a mac mini can seem steep compared to
$200 for Wii,
$250 for XBox 360, or
$300 for a PS3,
but mac mini offers an unparalleled feature set. By having a standard web browser, the mac mini gives you everything on the Internet — so much stuff that I wouldn’t be able to list everything in this note. More audio and video content than you can shake a stick at. The Mac mini, unlike the Wii, is capable of playing HD video, so all you have to do is find the HD content (streaming Netflix, iTunes, YouTube, BitTorrent, etc.) And there are enough games capable of running well on the mac mini that, although the graphics won’t necessarily be as good as XBox 360 or a high end PC, all but the pickiest and most hardcore gamers can be satisfied.
The mac mini is about to be refreshed. The 2009 mac mini (what I have) plays HD content without any trouble, mainly due to the updated NVIDIA GeForce 9400M graphics card. The new mini will no doubt be more capable, smaller, and/or cheaper, so there’s no doubt in my mind it will be an excellent machine to connect to an HDTV.
The setup I’ve described also has very few cables.
A word of caution. The mac mini runs best when at least two memory slots are filled. This means you can get a great performance boost for $70 (2 2GB ram sticks). Doing this upgrade requires you to open up the machine though, which is a bit tricky (but not impossible). In the process of upgrading my own machine, I stripped one of the tiny screws while putting it back together (doh!) and broke a little plastic piece connected to a wifi antenna. This has no impact on the performance of the machine, but it does void my warranty (which will be up soon anyway) and make it more difficult for me to upgrade the internal hard drive. Upgrading the hard drive is something I’d want to do ideally, since then I wouldn’t have to have an external drive, which is actually bigger than the mini itself and adds unnecessary cords and power consumption.
Downsides. The mac mini’s DVD drive is louder than others, but not intolerable. The cost isn’t ideal but is justified by the benefits. The mac mini doesn’t play blu-rays, so you won’t be able to take full advantage of the “HDTV experience,” but the online HD content is good enough, and I expect it will only get better with time. Reading on the tav kinda sucks, not going to lie, but if you pump up the magnification in the web browser, it’s not absolutely terrible. You won’t be reading novels off it though (get a refurbished Kindle for that).